Data-driven Design of Randomized Control Trials with Guaranteed Treatment Effects

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) generate guarantees for treatment effects. However, RCTs often spend unnecessary resources exploring sub-optimal treatments, which can reduce the power of treatment guarantees. To address this, we propose a two-stage RCT design. In the first stage, a data-driven screening procedure prunes low-impact treatments, while the second stage focuses on developing high-probability lower bounds for the best-performing treatment effect. Unlike existing adaptive RCT frameworks, our method is simple enough to be implemented in scenarios with limited adaptivity.We derive optimal designs for two-stage RCTs and demonstrate how such designs can be implemented through sample splitting.Empirically, we demonstrate that two-stage designs improve upon single-stage approaches, especially for scenarios where domain knowledge is available through a prior. Our work is thus, a simple yet effective design for RCTs, optimizing for the ability to certify with high probability the largest possible treatment effect for at least one of the arms studied.